Mantis - neon
Viewing Issue Advanced Details
4281 packaging major always 2010-02-16 20:20 2010-03-15 12:02
skayser  
dam  
normal  
closed  
fixed  
none    
none  
0004281: Causes subversion to pull in X11 libs (neon depends on libproxy which in turn depends on X11)
Just installed subversion on a test system and pkgutil pulled in a whole lot more than I expected, namely the CSW X11 libs stack via neon -> libproxy. I don't mind for the test system, but I can imagine people with systems where they _don't_ want to install such a depedency list only to use subversion.

# pkgutil -i subversion
...
Fetching CSWx11common-1.0,REV=2009.05.24 (1/20)...
Fetching CSWlibxau-1.0.4,REV=2009.06.04 (2/20)...
Fetching CSWlibxcb-1.3,REV=2009.06.07 (3/20)...
Fetching CSWlibice-1.0.6,REV=2009.09.22 (4/20)...
Fetching CSWlibx11-1.2.2,REV=2009.07.12 (5/20)...
Fetching CSWlibxt-1.0.6,REV=2009.09.25 (6/20)...
Fetching CSWlibxext-1.0.5,REV=2009.09.22 (7/20)...
Fetching CSWlibsm-1.1.1,REV=2009.09.23 (8/20)...
Fetching CSWlibxmu-1.0.4,REV=2009.09.25 (9/20)...
Fetching CSWlibproxy-0.3.0,REV=2010.01.18 (10/20)...
Fetching CSWpakchois-0.4,REV=2009.10.08 (11/20)...
Fetching CSWkrb5lib-1.4.4,REV=2006.12.27 (12/20)...
Fetching CSWexpat-2.0.1,REV=2009.01.22 (13/20)...
Fetching CSWsqlite3-3.6.21,REV=2010.01.04 (14/20)...
Fetching CSWperl-5.8.8,REV=2009.11.12 (15/20)...
Fetching CSWgsed-4.2.1,REV=2009.07.14 (16/20)...
Fetching CSWbdb-4.7.25,REV=2009.10.18 (17/20)...
Fetching CSWneon-0.29.3,REV=2010.01.19 (18/20)...
Fetching CSWapache2rt-2.2.13,REV=2009.08.22 (19/20)...
Fetching CSWsvn-1.6.6,REV=2009.11.14 (20/20)...
# pkgparam CSWsvn VERSION
1.6.6,REV=2009.11.14
# pkgparam CSWneon VERSION
0.29.3,REV=2010.01.19
# pkgparam CSWlibproxy VERSION
0.3.0,REV=2010.01.18
related to 0004307resolved hson libproxy split libproxy package to remove X deps 
Issue History
2010-02-16 20:20 skayser New Issue
2010-02-19 22:26 dam Status new => assigned
2010-02-19 22:26 dam Assigned To => dam
2010-02-19 22:27 dam Note Added: 0007480
2010-02-26 21:52 dam Relationship added related to 0004307
2010-02-26 21:55 dam Note Added: 0007536
2010-02-26 21:55 dam Status assigned => feedback
2010-03-15 12:02 dam Note Added: 0007648
2010-03-15 12:02 dam Status feedback => closed
2010-03-15 12:02 dam Resolution open => fixed

Notes
(0007480)
dam   
2010-02-19 22:27   
Plan is to build two libraries, one with minimal, one with full dependencies in packages CSWneon and CSWneonfancy switched via alternatives where neonfancy has higher priority.
(0007536)
dam   
2010-02-26 21:55   
Version 0.29.3,REV=2010.02.25 with alternatives support available at
  http://mirror.opencsw.org/experimental.html#alternatives [^]
for testing.
(0007648)
dam   
2010-03-15 12:02   
This has been address in 0.29.3,REV=2010.02.25. There are now two package alternatives: CSWneon with minimal dependencies and CSWneonfull with full dependencies. The latter one takes precedence if installed, all packages depend on the prior one.